Showing posts with label top 6. Show all posts
Showing posts with label top 6. Show all posts

Thursday, July 29, 2010

Poll of the week: Pickler picked once again among sixth-placers

In what had to be the most competitive round of IDOL LIVE's 2010 edition of the poll of the week champion series, Season 5's Kellie Pickler ruled her fellow sixth-place finalists.

Kellie nabbed 13 votes, or 35% of all 37 votes cast, compared with Season 7's Carly Smithson's 12 votes (32%) and the club's newest member, Siobhan Magnus of Season 9, at nine votes (24%). These three independent women were the only ones who really excited IDOL LIVE readers, and it's easy to see why when considering their not so popular comrades from the six other seasons.

In the next round, readers will be asked which 5th-place finalist is their favorite of all nine seasons. Voting will be open for exactly one week.

Christina Christian 0 (0%)
Carmen Rasmussen 1 (2%)
John Stevens 0 (0%)
Constantine Maroulis 0 (0%)
Kellie Pickler 13 (35%)
Phil Stacey 0 (0%)
Carly Smithson 12 (32%)
Anoop Desai 2 (5%)
Siobhan Magnus 9 (24%)

Total votes: 37

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Wednesday, April 28, 2010

Special commentary re: Siobhan Magnus

I'd like to take this opportunity to say that I've been wrong on a lot of my predictions this season. In fact, I think I've only called two boots correctly in the Top 12 so far, which is especially bad for me. But for someone who pegged Siobhan Magnus to win the whole thing at the outset of the Top 12, tonight's results are even more disappointing than usual.

Even though she was never one of my favorites, I respected Siobhan's fearlessness and the way she was able to switch up her performance styles from week to week. It was also cool that a fellow Massachusetts resident was able to make it as far as she did. And then she just seemed like an all around cool person to hang out with. Sadly, however, it was not her title to earn, but it's really frustrating that the likes of Aaron Kelly and Mike Lynche have now outlasted her. They are two of the most overrated contestants of the season, and the fact that they're still there is inexplicable.

Regardless, Siobhan should go on to bigger and better things, most likely on Broadway, and Randy Jackson was right to tell her to be herself. If she does just that, things should go quite well for Season 9's spunky firecracker with a distinguished screech.

P.S. this season blows big time.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Poll of the week: Siobhan Magnus favorite Top 6 contestant

In what was a surprising premature exit, Siobhan Magnus ended up garnering the most votes in a cruel case of irony on IDOL LIVE"s poll of the week for the Top 6 edition of the poll.

Siobhan took in 38 of the 129 votes cast, good for 29% of the total take. Lee DeWyze was next with 22% of the vote thanks to 29 votes in his favor, while Casey James was right behind with 28 votes (21%).

Onetime favorite Crystal Bowersox slipped to fourth place with 16 votes (12%), while Aaron Kelly was next with 12 votes (9%) and Big Mike Lynche was dead last with six votes (4%).

In another case of irony, the season to date rankings show that Siobhan is now IDOL LIVE readers' finalist of choice, as she leads with 218 votes to second-place contestant Crystal (198 votes).

In the latest edition of the poll of the week series, readers are asked who their favorite Top 5 contestant is. Voting will be open for exactly one week.

Aaron Kelly 12 (9%)
Casey James 28 (21%)
Crystal Bowersox 16 (12%)
Lee DeWyze 29 (22%)
Mike Lynche 6 (4%)
Siobhan Magnus 38 (29%)

Total votes: 129

Running total for Season 9:
24th - Haeley Vaughn (0 votes)*
21st (tie) - Janell Wheeler (2 votes)*
21st (tie) - Todrick Hall (2 votes)*
21st (tie) - Paige Miles (2 votes)*
19th (tie) - Joe Munoz (3 votes)*
19th (tie) - Jermaine Sellers (3 vote)*
17th (tie) - Tyler Grady (4 votes)*
17th (tie) - Michelle Delamor (4 votes)*
15th (tie) - John Park (6 votes)*
15th (tie) - Ashley Rodriguez (6 votes)*
14th - Lacey Brown (9 votes)*
13th - Katelyn Epperly (10 votes)*
12th - Lilly Scott (14 votes)*
10th (tie) - Michael Lynche (22 votes)
10th (tie) - Alex Lambert (22 votes)*
09th - Didi Benami (56 votes)*
08th - Andrew Garcia (58 votes)*
07th - Tim Urban (60 votes)*
06th - Casey James (92 votes)
05th - Katie Stevens (93 votes)*
04th - Aaron Kelly (97 votes)
03rd - Lee DeWyze (178 votes)
02nd - Crystal Bowersox (198 votes)
01st - Siobhan Magnus (218 votes)*

*indicates contestant has been eliminated

[+/-] Show Full Post...

IDOL LIVE Blog - Top 6 Results (4/28/10)

Last night was nice mostly because it didn't run over, but there were also a few decent performances. Maybe it's because we're getting down to the wire and the majority of the cannon fodder are gone? Or maybe it's just the standards have been lowered so much that they have nowhere to go but up? Either way, I'll refrain from complaining.

Tonight we surprisingly cannot expect a performance from this week's mentor, Shania Twain, however Lady Antebellum, Rascal Flatts and...Shakira...will all be there to perform. To see who I predict will be leaving tonight, see here.

Please feel free to add your two cents throughout the one-hour blogcast, with coverage starting just prior to 9 p.m. ET.



Tonight's blogcast features the music of Daughtry, Jasmine Murray, Katharine McPhee, Kristy Lee Cook, Matt Giraud.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

IDOL LIVE predix: Top 6 Results

So that was interesting. No one really did horribly performing in front of Shania Twain, although I thought Mike Lynche and Siobhan Magnus were very overpraised by the judges (and Lee DeWyze might have got a smidge too much praise as well). That said, Siobhan got the abundant praise because she really needed it, coming off a few rough weeks and being the owner of the esteemed pimp spot last night played large roles in the judges' critiques of her. As for Mike's overpraise, I'm not really sure what that was about, but in the end it might end up doing him more harm than good.

With that said, read my predictions for how tonight will go below:

Bottom 3
Crystal, Aaron, Mike

Bottom 2
Aaron, Mike

Eliminated
Mike

Yes, that's Crystal Bowersox you see included in the Bottom 3 grouping. Something about last night's performance, especially when matched up against her five competitors, just didn't help her stand out from the crowd. In fact, she didn't even have the best vocals of the night, which is a distinction she almost always has. Therefore, even though she has a huge fan base, it might take the night off due to complacency whereas the younger fans of the likes of Siobhan, Aaron and Lee will be dialing and texting their fingers off, which will result in a SURPRISE! B3 visit for Crystal.

Obviously she won't really be in danger, though, while Aaron Kelly will feel the heat much more despite delivering a mostly on point performance of Shania's "You've Got a Way," but the idea of him dedicating the song to his mom, as sweet as it may seem to some, might have been viewed as a ploy for votes by others. What it comes down to at this point is the fact that Aaron's fan base just isn't as big as the majority of the others' and he's not really one to appeal to the casual voters. Expect a bottom two placement, nothing more, nothing less.

At that leaves us with Big Mike. There probably isn't a better week for Mike to go out on than country/Shania Twain, because let's face it, most of his fans are probably not likely to also be fans of the genre or the Queen of Country herself. Couple this with Mike's history of being in the bottom group and what should have been his elimination back in Top 9 week and you've got yourself a recipe for disaster. This isn't to say Mike would have gone a lot farther had there been a friendlier theme for his vocals, like Luther Vandross' songbook, but the odds are even tougher for him.

In my original predictions I had Mike going home 6th, so hopefully everything goes according to plan.

Since the Top 24 I have correctly predicted 6-18 eliminations and since the Top 12 I have correctly predicted 2-6 eliminations.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Tuesday, April 27, 2010

IDOL LIVE Blog - Top 6 Perform (4/27/10)

Tonight the Top 6 finalists sample entries from the songbook of Shania Twain, which will be the closest this crop comes to being forced to perform country music. That means Aaron Kelly should be in his element and virtually be protected from elimination unless he picks something on the scale of "(Man) I Feel Like a Woman," which I wouldn't put past him.

As always, please feel free to add your two cents throughout the (allegedly) one-hour blogcast, with coverage starting just prior to 8 p.m. ET.



Tonight's blogcast features the music of Amanda Overmyer, Elliott Yamin, Kellie Pickler, LaKisha Jones and Michael Sarver.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Monday, April 26, 2010

Flashback: Anoop Desai's "Dim All the Lights"

It was only a year ago that Anoop Desai was a casualty of the judges' save, as he was eliminated in sixth place during Disco week. Anoop gave it his all on his rendition of Donna Summer's "Dim All the Lights" (and even got the coveted pimp spot) but it wasn't enough to overcome. Watch the performance below:



Anoop actually did very well on the song and the judges sans Simon seemed on board the Anoop train as well. Fortunately for Anoop, this showing hasn't seemed to scar him in the long run.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Monday, August 31, 2009

Flashback: Anthony Fedorov's "I Surrender"

Anthony Fedorov surprised many as a darkhorse on Idol's fourth season, though he was never able to escape the shadow of good friend and eventual champ Carrie Underwood. One of his standout performances came Top 6 week when he took on Celine Dion's big ballad "I Surrender" for 21st Century theme night. Relive the performance below:



Despite the vocal acrobatics Anthony showed off during this performance, it was not enough to keep him from visiting the bottom two, where he was spared elimination in favor of Constantine Maroulis. Still, Anthony was able to last another two weeks, and this performance can largely be deemed responsible for extending his stay on the show.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Poll of the week: Fans still pick Pickler

It was a spirited week of voting on IDOL LIVE's poll of the week champion series for the favorite sixth-place finalist of all eight seasons, and the competition broke the win streak of Season 7 finalists for the first time this voting period.

Leave it to Kellie Pickler and her faithful fans to stand in the way of Carly Smithson and her equally passionate fans. The fifth season's lovable country star netted 296 of the 582 total votes, which equated to 50%. In comparison, Carly was able to take in 267 votes (45%). The two were tied in the count with just one hour left to vote, which is when Kellie's fans eked out a win by fewer than 30 votes.

The poll's six other contenders failed to excite voters, as Anoop Desai only took in nine votes (1%), and Constantine Maroulis was only able to generate six votes (1%).

In the next installment of IDOL LIVE's poll of the week champion series, readers are asked which fifth-place finalist is their favorite of all eight seasons. Voting will be open for exactly one week.

Christina Christian 2 (0%)
Carmen Rasmusen 0 (0%)
John Stevens 0 (0%)
Constantine Maroulis 6 (1%)
Kellie Pickler 296 (50%)
Phil Stacey 2 (0%)
Carly Smithson 267 (45%)
Anoop Desai 9 (1%)

Total votes: 582

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Thursday, April 24, 2008

Carly's exit is a semi-surprise


Although it was intended to send shockwaves across America when Ryan uttered the words "Brooke, you're safe" last night, it really was not a huge surprise. Although her now infamous restart was the talk of the town, and Ryan mentioned it on multiple occasions last night alone, Brooke White's maturity after the performance on Tuesday was remarkable. She stood there with her lips pursed, accepting the criticism that she knew she would be getting. She did not talk over the judges, something she made note of before her results were read last night.

It was a definite shame, however, that Ireland's Carly Smithson was sent packing. Her performance of "Superstar" on Tuesday was arguably the best of the night, and so although it was not a complete shock, it did feel a bit undeserving. The fact that Carly went out all smiles and with class was good to see, and Simon even gave her praise, telling her to hold her head up high and be proud of what she accomplished, which was interesting considering their somewhat rocky relationship onstage over the course of the season.

Last night, most of America was introduced to Leona Lewis, the UK's X-Factor winner and Simon discovery. Lewis looked beautiful in a white knee-length dress, and the lighting made her seem angelic. It was definitely one of the best guest performances of the season, if not the best. The flames were a nice added touch as well.

One aspect that was not missed during the results show was the "Idol Live" segment (serves them right for stealing the name), as it is the filler of all fillers. Ryan's chat with Andrew Lloyd Webber was interesting, and gave more insight into why he gave advice to certain contestants. When asked if Jason followed his advice, he said "no," and commented on the song choice being "peculiar." He also thought Brooke was flawless in the dress rehearsal, which goes to show how she would have sounded had she not restarted.

When Simon brought out David Archuleta and David Cook to kick off the results, everyone knew what was coming. But the fact that Syesha Mercado landed in the bottom two with Carly was a sad but real circumstance that the remaining five finalists will have to deal with from here on in. Every week is do or die, and one wrong move could end their dreams of winning.

Although it may seem obvious that the next three to leave are Syesha, Jason Castro and Brooke (and probably in that order), nothing is set in stone. At this point in Season 5, everyone and their mother had Chris Daughtry picked as the winner, but we all know how that turned out. Just something to keep in mind as we march toward May 21.

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Finalists show their theatrical sides on ALW night

If the Top 6 finalists do not win American Idol, they can at least find comfort in knowing they could succeed on Broadway. Well, most of them anyway.

The theme of songs from Andrew Lloyd Webber's catalog was something that has never been done on the show, and could have been a disaster. Instead, the finalists took Webber's advice to heart and actually put on a few memorable performances.

First up was Syesha Mercado, who took on "One Rock 'n Roll Too Many" from Starlight. After Webber decided Syesha should go with her "animated" version over the "un-animated" version, it was apparent to see why he made the decision. She tore up the stage in a low-cut red dress and invoked a lot of sass into her performance. A cameo by Ricky Minor dressed in era attire was also a refreshing twist.

Randy and Paula kept pushing the Broadway thing on Syesha, as Paula called it "her happy place." Simon agreed with Randy, saying she is "comfortable" in the style of music, and called the performance "sexy." It would not be a surprise to see her in the bottom two, but in all likelihood she will escape it this week.

Brooke White, on the other hand, suffered a stumble when she had to restart her performance of "You Must Love Me" from the film adaptation of Evita. Although Webber said Brooke "sang it like she meant it" during their session together, he abrupt restart ended up throwing her off, and she never really recovered. Vocally, it was her weakest performance to date.

Paula had a long pause of her own during her critique, and finally came out with "You must never start and stop." Simon disagreed, saying he would have done the same thing had he flubbed the lyrics. But he also warned Brooke that she would be disappointed upon watching her performance back. A definite bottom 2 appearance tonight.

Jason Castro was the second sub-par performance of the night, as he struggled his way through "Memory" from Cats. ALW seemed to be having fun with Jason, making light of his dreadlocks, but said he would not be surprised if Jason disregarded his advice completely and ended up sounding better. Whatever he did, it did not work out. Jason spent the majority of the performance staring down at the floor, staying planted in a stool throughout the duration. His vocals were also wishy washy and he never really seemed to find a comfort zone.

Randy went as far as calling it a "train wreck" vocally, but Paula gave him credit for singing something a female power-singng balladeer would sing. Simon compared the performance to a little boy being forced to sing a song at a wedding by his parents but making the whole scene miserable. Jason could make the bottom 2, but he will most likely just scrape by, having the third-lowest votes.

The night did improve as it went on. David Archuleta sang "Think of Me" from Phantom of the Opera. He was vocally on par but it was not he greatest performance. If there was one good thing about it, though, it was the fact that David actually listened to ALW's advice that he keep his eyes open as much as possible, as he only closed them a few times.

Randy seemed like a cheerleader during his critique, as he went above and beyond with his praise for the performance. Paula also reached a bit high, calling it "absolutely perfect." But leave it to Simon to get things right once again, as he called it "pleasant but probably one of [David's] weakest performances." Watch as David sails through to take on "Sweet Caroline" next week.

Carly Smithson also put on one of the highlights (if not the highlight) of her time on the show with "Superstar" from Jesus Christ Superstar. The performance was upbeat and lively, something she really needed to do. And ALW gave her some of the best advice a mentor had ever given a contestant, after making her change her song. He also said she looked really happy singing it.

The incorporation of the band and Carly's movement all around the stage added to the overall package, and she received mild praise from the judges (a bit too mild). Simon did say it was "one of his favorite performances of the night," which counts for something. Despite having a standout performance, it looks like Carly will in fact be in the bottom 2, and more than likely she will (undeservingly) go home.

The show was able to go out on a good note, but nothing as lively as Carly's performance. David Cook pulled out a win in "Music of the Night" from Phantom of the Opera, and the highlight of the entire show came during his mentor session with ALW. Trying to get it across to David that the song is romantic and that he needed to imagine he was singing it to the most beautiful girl he had ever seen, Webber asked David to imagine him as a "17-year-old girl," which drew laughs from the audience (and most likely all of America).

David was very controlled, on cue and technically a good vocalist on the song, as he was able to bring out opera elements that he had never shown on the show. It bordered on boring a few times, but he was able to finish on a signature "Cook" note. Two judges were wild about it, but the other one not so much. Simon said he preferred the "gritty rocker" side of David over the theatrical one, something most of his fans also would agree with.

So as it stands, it looks like Ryan will play games with the finalists tonight and separate them all into three groups of two, and then announce which one is the bottom group. If one was to put money on the outcome, it does not look good for Carly nor Brooke, but worse for Carly thanks to the sympathy vote for Brooke. Whatever happens, it will be awfully close.

Predictions:
Bottom 2: Brooke, Carly
Eliminated: Carly

[+/-] Show Full Post...

Search & Win